In short
A broker is cheaper, a robo-advisor is more convenient. With a broker like Yuh or neon you pick your ETFs yourself and pay almost nothing in the savings plan. A robo-advisor like finpension or findependent invests and rebalances for you, for approx. 0.4 to 0.9% a year all-in. My overall winner is finpension, closely followed by Yuh.
🎁 My promo codes for you
*Affiliate codes. You get the bonus, I may get a small commission. No extra cost for you.
⭐ My rating: brokers and robo-advisors ranked
All seven providers in one ranking. Brokers are cheaper if you decide yourself, robo-advisors take the work off your hands.

finpension Invest
Robo-advisor with index funds
🤖 Best robo-advisorPros
- Approx. 0.47% a year all-in, flat
- Start from CHF 1
- Automatically diversified and rebalanced
Cons
- No personal advice
- Limited strategy customisation

Yuh
Bank, card and investing in one app
🏆 Best broker savings planPros
- 21 ETFs without purchase fee in the savings plan
- Savings plan from CHF 10, fractional
- No custody fee
Cons
- 0.95% currency exchange
- 0.5% per trade outside the free ETFs

Swissquote
Largest Swiss online broker
🧺 Biggest choicePros
- Savings plan on approx. 100 ETFs, fractional
- CHF 3 per savings plan transaction
- Share register and huge product range
Cons
- Custody fee CHF 80 to 200 a year
- Tax statement CHF 85

findependent
Swiss robo-advisor with ETFs
💸 Lowest robo costsPros
- 0.40 to 0.65% a year all-in
- First CHF 2.000 fee-free with code
- Automatic rebalancing
Cons
- Start from CHF 500
- Limited strategy customisation

neon invest
Investing in the free neon app
🔁 Free ETF savings plansPros
- 20+ ETFs without purchase fee in the savings plan
- No custody fee
- Free tax statement
Cons
- Smaller choice
- No fractional trading
Saxo
Swiss bank with global trading platform
💸 Low trading feesPros
- Over 100 ETFs in AutoInvest without purchase fee
- Only 0.08% per trade, at least CHF 3
- Currency exchange approx. 0.25%
Cons
- App is more complex
- No payment account with card

Selma
Robo-advisor with personal guidance
🤝 More guidancePros
- Personal strategy and retirement mode
- Guidance in the app
- Invests automatically in ETFs
Cons
- 0.64 to 0.90% a year all-in
- Start from CHF 2.000
My personal rating, as of November 2026. The score applies to this comparison and may differ in another one. Not financial advice. An affiliate code does not influence the score. *Advertising, affiliate codes.
Broker vs robo-advisor: the key differences
| Criterion | 📱 Broker (Yuh, neon, Saxo) | 🤖 Robo-advisor (finpension, findependent) |
|---|---|---|
| Costs per year | approx. 0.1 to 0.3% (ETF fee only) | approx. 0.4 to 0.9% all-in |
| Effort | you choose and rebalance | fully automatic |
| Flexibility | any ETF or share | predefined strategies |
| Best for | people who like to decide | people with little time |
What the difference costs over 20 years
Example: CHF 300 a month for 20 years at 5% return before costs. With a broker at approx. 0.2% a year you end up with roughly CHF 121,000. With a robo-advisor at approx. 0.5% it is roughly CHF 116,000. The difference of about CHF 4,500 is the price of convenience, and for many people it is worth it.
Simplified calculation, rounded, without taxes. Not a forecast.
Take a broker if you …
- want the lowest possible costs
- are fine with one world ETF
- enjoy checking your portfolio once a year
Take a robo-advisor if you …
- never want to think about rebalancing
- want a strategy that fits your risk
- like to start with very small amounts
Want to dig deeper? See my ETF savings plan comparison and the robo-advisor ranking.
⭐ More comparisons with ratings
Same method, honest scores and my codes.
🎁 Exclusive for my readers
Start with a welcome bonus
Tap a code to copy it and enter it when you open your account.

Swiss bank and broker, shares and ETFs worldwide.
CHF 100
trading credits after depositing CHF 1’000 within 30 days
Get CHF 100 →
Free account, card, TWINT and investing from CHF 10.
CHF 50 + 250 SWQ
trading credits and Swissqoins after depositing CHF 500
Get CHF 50 →
Low-cost pillar 3a with ETFs, save taxes every year.
CHF 25
credit for pillar 3a, vested benefits or Invest
Get CHF 25 →*Advertising, affiliate codes. Only for residents of Switzerland, bonus conditions apply. This costs you nothing extra.
Frequently asked questions
Is a broker or a robo-advisor better for beginners?
Both work. A robo-advisor is easier because it does everything for you. A broker like Yuh is cheaper if you are happy to choose one world ETF.
How much does a robo-advisor cost in Switzerland?
Approx. 0.40 to 0.95% a year all-in, depending on provider and amount. finpension charges approx. 0.47% flat.
Can I combine both?
Yes. Many people use a robo-advisor for their pillar 3a and a broker for free assets.
Is my money safe with a robo-advisor?
Securities are segregated assets and belong to you, even if the provider goes bankrupt.
My verdict
If costs come first, choose a broker savings plan with Yuh or neon. If convenience comes first, choose finpension or findependent. With my codes you start with a bonus either way.
All information without guarantee, as of November 2026. Please check current conditions with the provider. Not financial advice.
