Index duel Β· Updated 17 November 2026 Β· approx. 8 min read Β· by Helga Baechler, certified wealth advisor IAF
In short
The S&P 500 has been stronger in recent years, the MSCI World spreads your risk more widely. The S&P 500 holds 500 US companies only, the MSCI World approx. 1,300 companies from 23 developed countries. My rating: MSCI World 8.5, S&P 500 7.8.
π My promo codes for you
*Advertising, affiliate codes. This costs you nothing extra.
MSCI World vs S&P 500 at a glance
| MSCI World | S&P 500 | |
|---|---|---|
| Rating | β β β β β 8.5 | β β β β β 7.8 |
| Companies | approx. 1,300 | 500 |
| Countries | 23 developed markets | USA only |
| US share | approx. 72% | 100% |
| Costs (TER) | from approx. 0.06% | from approx. 0.05% |
| Example ETFs | iShares Core SWDA, UBS Core, Xtrackers | Vanguard VUAA/VUSA, iShares CSPX, Invesco |
What is the difference, simply explained?
The S&P 500 contains the 500 largest listed companies in the US. The MSCI World also contains these US giants, but adds hundreds of companies from Europe, Japan, Canada, Australia and Switzerland, for example NestlΓ©, Novartis and Roche.
Because US companies are so big, they still make up approx. 72% of the MSCI World. That is why both indices move in a similar way most of the time. The difference shows in phases when the US does much better or much worse than the rest of the world.
The US dollar risk for Swiss investors
With an S&P 500 ETF, 100% of your money is invested in US dollar companies. With the MSCI World it is approx. 72%, the rest is spread across euro, yen, pound, Swiss franc and other currencies. If the US dollar loses value against the Swiss franc, your return in francs goes down, even if US shares rise. A broader index softens this effect.
Savings plan example: CHF 200 a month
| Years | Paid in | MSCI World (8%) | S&P 500 (10%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | CHF 24,000 | approx. CHF 36,600 | approx. CHF 41,000 |
| 20 | CHF 48,000 | approx. CHF 117,800 | approx. CHF 151,900 |
| 30 | CHF 72,000 | approx. CHF 298,100 | approx. CHF 452,100 |
Assumed returns based on the past, not a forecast. The US may not outperform in the future.
β My rating: MSCI World vs S&P 500
MSCI World
For you if you add emerging markets separately
π§Ί Biggest choicePros
- approx. 1,300 companies from 23 developed markets
- TER from approx. 0.06%
- Huge choice of ETFs
Cons
- No emerging markets
- US share approx. 72%, high cluster risk
S&P 500
For you if you deliberately bet on the US economy
πΊπΈ Pure US focusPros
- The 500 largest US companies
- TER from approx. 0.05%
- Very strong historic return
Cons
- One country only, 100% USA
- Heavy dependence on a few tech companies
My personal rating, as of November 2026. The score applies to this comparison. Not financial advice. *Advertising, affiliate codes.
Which one suits you?
- Broad, calm core: MSCI World or even FTSE All-World.
- Deliberate bet on the US: S&P 500 as a satellite next to a world ETF.
Core and satellite: how much US do you end up with?
Many investors hold a world ETF as their core and add a smaller S&P 500 position. This is how your US share changes.
| Mix | Your US share |
|---|---|
| 100% MSCI World | approx. 72% |
| 80% MSCI World, 20% S&P 500 | approx. 78% |
| 80% FTSE All-World, 20% S&P 500 | approx. 70% |
| 100% S&P 500 | 100% |
Calculated with a US share of approx. 72% for the MSCI World and approx. 62% for the FTSE All-World. More in FTSE All-World vs MSCI World.
Adding the S&P 500 to an MSCI World ETF changes little, because the US is already the largest part. It mainly makes sense if you deliberately want more US.
β More comparisons with ratings
- FTSE All-World vs MSCI World
- World ETF comparison
- ETF savings plan Switzerland
- Best broker in Switzerland
π Exclusive for my readers
Start with a welcome bonus
Tap a code to copy it and enter it when you open your account.

Swiss bank and broker, shares and ETFs worldwide.
CHF 100
trading credits after depositing CHF 1’000 within 30 days
Get CHF 100 β
Free account, card, TWINT and investing from CHF 10.
CHF 50 + 250 SWQ
trading credits and Swissqoins after depositing CHF 500
Get CHF 50 β
Low-cost pillar 3a with ETFs, save taxes every year.
CHF 25
credit for pillar 3a, vested benefits or Invest
Get CHF 25 β*Advertising, affiliate codes. Only for residents of Switzerland, bonus conditions apply. This costs you nothing extra.
Frequently asked questions
Is the S&P 500 better than the MSCI World?
It was stronger in the last decade, but it is riskier because it depends on one country.
Can I combine both?
Yes, but they overlap heavily because the MSCI World is already approx. 72% US.
Which ETFs track the S&P 500?
For example Vanguard S&P 500 (VUAA accumulating, VUSA distributing), iShares Core S&P 500 (CSPX) and ETFs from Invesco.
Is the S&P 500 enough as my only ETF?
It is possible, but then all your money depends on one country and one currency. As a core I prefer a world ETF.
Does the US dollar matter for me in Switzerland?
Yes. If the dollar falls against the franc, your return in francs goes down. With the S&P 500 this effect is stronger than with the MSCI World.
Does the past return say anything about the future?
No. The 8% and 10% in the savings plan example are assumptions based on the past. Nobody knows which index will be stronger in the next 20 years.
My verdict
As a core I prefer the MSCI World or a full world ETF. The S&P 500 works as a conscious US satellite.
My personal rating of the indices, as of November 2026. Not financial advice.
